SciPost Submission Page
2group global symmetries, hydrodynamics and holography
by Nabil Iqbal, Napat Poovuttikul
This is not the latest submitted version.
This Submission thread is now published as
Submission summary
Authors (as registered SciPost users):  Nabil Iqbal · Nick Poovuttikul 
Submission information  

Preprint Link:  scipost_202111_00023v1 (pdf) 
Date submitted:  20211114 22:26 
Submitted by:  Poovuttikul, Nick 
Submitted to:  SciPost Physics 
Ontological classification  

Academic field:  Physics 
Specialties: 

Approach:  Theoretical 
Abstract
We construct a theory of hydrodynamics describing the finitetemperature realization of a 2group global symmetry composed out of $U(1)$ zeroform and $U(1)$ oneform symmetries. We study aspects of the thermodynamics from a Euclidean partition function and derive constitutive relations for ideal hydrodynamics from various points of view. Novel features of the resulting theory include an analogue of the chiral magnetic effect and a chiral sound mode propagating along magnetic field lines. We also discuss a minimalist holographic description of a theory dual to 2group global symmetry and verify predictions of the hydrodynamic description.Along the way we clarify some aspects of symmetry breaking in higherform theories at finite temperature.
Current status:
Reports on this Submission
Report #2 by Anonymous (Referee 2) on 2022514 (Invited Report)
 Cite as: Anonymous, Report on arXiv:scipost_202111_00023v1, delivered 20220514, doi: 10.21468/SciPost.Report.5076
Report
The paper develops the formalism to study the state of thermal equilibrium in a fluid that is endowed with a 2group global symmetry structure. The authors study a fluid with an ordinary 1form current intertwined with a conserved 2form current via the 2group Ward identities. They construct the most general equilibrium constitutive relations for such a fluid. In particular, they provide an impressive detailed exposition of the construction of the equilibrium partition function, which is invariant under diffeomorphisms as well as the gauge transformations of the 1form and 2form background gauge fields which couple to their respective currents, by introducing Stueckelberg fields into their setup. The equilibrium partition function, which gets further constrained due to the shift symmetries associated with the Stueckelberg fields, gives rise to the aforementioned constitutive relations when varied with respect to the background sources. Additionally, the authors also discuss deriving the same equilibrium constitutive relations via an entropy current analysis in Appendix A of the paper, lending further credibility to their equilibrium partition function approach.
Furthermore, the authors discuss some of the interesting hydrodynamic modes of the system, along with their physical interpretation. Section IV then proposes a working holographic dual to their setup, which is able to capture these hydrodynamic modes faithfully. In particular, in their holographic setup, the authors do a very nice job of clearly explaining how the shift symmetries of the Stueckelberg fields of the boundary theory are realized in the radial gauge in the dual bulk description.
The paper opens up the possibility of exploring several new avenues, including but not limited to the study of 2group symmetries in hydrodynamics with other constituent group structures; the possibility of breaking the 2group symmetry structure spontaneously or explicitly and studying the ensuing affects on hydrodynamic transport; going beyond the ideal order and exploring dissipative corrections to the 2group Ward identities and constitutive relations etc. All in all, the paper is an interesting addition to the existing literature on hydrodynamics with higherform symmetries, which have received much attention lately.
There are a couple of questions which I would like the authors to comment upon in the paper, which would be helpful for a better understanding to the reader.
1. One of the key results of the paper is the existence of a 1form current along the direction of the magnetic field, even in an equilibrium state where the fluid is chosen to be at rest i.e. $u^\mu = (1, \vec{0})$. This is somewhat surprising, because if the fluid is at rest, then what is it that is flowing along the direction of $h^\mu$ in thermal equilibrium? In chiral magnetic effect, there too is a current flow along the direction of the magnetic field, but it is an $\mathcal{O}(\partial)$ effect, and not an equilibrium effect. The presence of a current of charged particles along the magnetic field when the fluid is at rest appears to be a mutually contradictory conclusion. It would be nice if the authors can provide a clean physical picture of what is happening here.
2. The concrete holographic model which the authors utilize for their calculations in Section IVB involves a 1form and a 2form gauge field propagating on an AdS$_5$Schwarzschild background spacetime. Thus they neglect the backreaction entirely. Why is this approximation justified? If one is working with a strongly coupled ordinary $U(1)$ charged fluid, without any higherform symmetry, the dual holographic description is provided by electrically charged black brane solutions to EinsteinMaxwell theory (or EinsteinMaxwellChernSimons theory if the boundary theory has a chiral anomaly) in thermal equilibrium. For the setup relevant to the current paper, one would expect a dual bulk spacetime geometry with both a 0form and 1form charge density on the black brane. Are such geometries discussed in the literature? It would be nice if the authors comment about the necessary limitations of their holographic analysis and the ensuing results, by not looking at the correct dual background geometry, but rather just a probe approximation to it.
Finally, some typos: The indices in eqs. (1.8a) and (1.8b) should be corrected, and factors of $\hat{\kappa}$ missing in eqs. (4.8), (4.9) and (4.10) should be restored.
Report #1 by Anonymous (Referee 1) on 2022419 (Invited Report)
 Cite as: Anonymous, Report on arXiv:scipost_202111_00023v1, delivered 20220419, doi: 10.21468/SciPost.Report.4939
Report
This manuscript is concerned with the hydrodynamic regime of QFTs with 2group symmetriesa particular current algebra involving 0form and 1form currents.The recent accounting of higherform symmetries in hydrodynamics has led to a more systematic description of the finite temperature dynamics of systems including magnetohydrodynamics [Ref. 4]. Anomalies for continuous global symmetries moreover are known to nonperturbatively fix certain transport parameters [e.g. Ref. [30]]. Given the difficulty of otherwise constraining transport in interacting systems, it is important to further establish other nonperturbative consequences of nontrivial current algebras, which the authors undertake.
The results of this paper  some of which are verified in holographic constructions  seem correct. One consequence of the 2group structure that the authors find is the chiral propagation of the collective mode associated with the 0form symmetry, along flux lines associated with the 1form symmetry, which themselves are dynamical.
Requested changes
None