SciPost Submission Page
Systematic strong coupling expansion for outofequilibrium dynamics in the LiebLiniger model
by Etienne Granet and Fabian H. L. Essler
This is not the latest submitted version.
This Submission thread is now published as
Submission summary
Authors (as registered SciPost users):  Fabian Essler · Etienne Granet 
Submission information  

Preprint Link:  scipost_202103_00015v1 (pdf) 
Date submitted:  20210314 19:38 
Submitted by:  Granet, Etienne 
Submitted to:  SciPost Physics 
Ontological classification  

Academic field:  Physics 
Specialties: 

Approach:  Theoretical 
Abstract
We consider the time evolution of local observables after an interaction quench in the repulsive LiebLiniger model. The system is initialized in the ground state for vanishing interaction and then timeevolved with the LiebLiniger Hamiltonian for large, finite interacting strength $c$. We employ the Quench Action approach to express the full time evolution of local observables in terms of sums over energy eigenstates and then derive the leading terms of a $1/c$ expansion for several one and twopoint functions as a function of time $t>0$ after the quantum quench. We observe delicate cancellations of contributions to the spectral sums that depend on the details of the choice of representative state in the Quench Action approach and our final results are independent of this choice. Our results provide a highly nontrivial confirmation of the typicality assumptions underlying the Quench Action approach.
Current status:
Reports on this Submission
Anonymous Report 1 on 2021412 (Invited Report)
 Cite as: Anonymous, Report on arXiv:scipost_202103_00015v1, delivered 20210412, doi: 10.21468/SciPost.Report.2785
Report
The authors address the exact computation of observables after a quantum quench in interacting integrable systems. They focus on a systematic strongcoupling expansion, which was already introduced by the authors in previous works. Here, for the first time, it is applied to the time evolution after a quench. The authors study the prototypical example of the LiebLiniger model, although the logic is more general and works, in principle, for more other systems and quenches.
Although necessarily technical, the paper is very well written. I appreciate that the main results are nicely presented in a dedicated section, and that the main formulas are illustrated with plots. Subsequent technical parts are also clearly organized and the discussion is always easy to follow.
The material and the research presented is timely, given the interest in the nonequilibrium dynamics of isolated systems. Furthermore, I find the results very strong. As the authors stress, there exist very few cases where analytic results of any form can be obtained beyond the noninteracting limit. In fact, I am genuinely impressed by the calculations, and by how the authors manage to arrive at compact and nice results, despite the length of intermediate steps.
Overall, I don't have particular comments on the draft, as I think the presentation is already very good, and the authors already did a good job in presenting the relevant literature. Therefore, I essentially recommend publication of this excellent work as is. I only have a couple of minor questions/remarks for the authors, which I present in the following.
First, I find interesting the discussion around Fig. 3, regarding the absence of lightcones. I understand the justification given by the authors, I think it is sound. However, lightcone effects are usually more visible in the shorttime regime, where, as the authors also mention, one might expect that a resummation of the perturbative series might be necessary in order to capture the relevant physics at finite interaction value. Therefore, is it possible that the absence of lightcones observed, e.g. in Fig. 3, is in fact an artifact of the truncation of the perturbative series? This would not be too surprising given that, contrary to the limit c=\infty, the energy of the initial state is finite for finite c.
I also have a few suggestions about references (however, I am not asking the authors to add them, if they think they are not relevant).
 In the conclusions, the authors mention that their work is the first one to obtain analytic results for the quench dynamics in a generic interacting integrable theory beyond the asymptotic latetime regime. I understand that here they refer to the dynamics of local observables, and I agree. More generally, however, analytic results have been obtained for other quantities after a quench, even in fully fledged interacting integrable systems such as the XXZ Heisenberg chain. One example is the realtime Loschmidt echo computed in
L. Piroli, B. Pozsgay, and E. Vernier, Nuclear Physics B 933, 454 (2018)
Furthermore, restricting to models with special limits or simple features, other examples exist. For instance, analytic results were also derived in
A. Cortés Cubero, J. Stat. Mech. 2016, 083107 (2016)
where exact results are obtained in the largeN limit of a matrixvalued quantum field theory. Finally, together with [85, 86] the authors might also consider adding a reference to
S. Sotiriadis, arXiv:2007.12683
S. Sotiriadis, arXiv:2010.03553
where the author also aims at a microscopic derivation of a GHDlike description of inhomogeneous quenches
Author: Etienne Granet on 20210625 [id 1528]
(in reply to Report 1 on 20210412)We thank the referee for their very positive comments about the draft.
Regarding the absence of lightcone: we agree that the series truncation might not be uniformly convergent near t=0, which would require resummation to get the correct t\to 0 behaviour of physical quantities. However, a lightcone would be observed in Fig 3 if there was a maximal quasiparticle velocity vmax, and so the connected correlator would be zero (or exponentially small) for all x> vmax t. This would thus be visible even for not small t, which is why we think this is not an artifact of the truncation of the series expansion.
Regarding the references: we focused indeed on results on local observables outofequilibrium. However we are happy to include the proposed references in the next version.